Finding exceptional seafood in Plattsburgh, NY feels a bit like stumbling onto a secret cove. One minute, you’re watching the sun flicker off Lake Champlain; the next, a forkful of lobster or a platter of fresh-caught fish is convincing you that yes, you really are this close to the source. On my last trip, I found myself savoring a plate of delicate scallops as a cool lake breeze drifted through the window. That meal lingered in my mind, not only for the flavor but for how seamlessly the city wears its maritime spirit.
Whether you’re a local or a traveler tracing the shores, you’ll discover that Plattsburgh’s seafood scene offers more than fried basics and fish sandwiches. Choices range from cozy waterside shacks to chic bistros where the menu reads like a love letter to the lake. I’ve sifted through the classics and surprises alike, curating a list of standout seafood spots—each worth your appetite, and your curiosity.
Where to find the best seafood in Plattsburgh, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Plattsburgh, NY:
- Mainely Lobster & Seafood
- Castaway On The Bay
- Irises Cafe and Wine Bar
- Naked Turtle
- Butcher Block Restaurant
- Latitude 44 Bistro
- Yama Sushi
- Happy Pike Ice Cream & Snack Bar
- Shanty On The Shore
- Bleu Northeast Kitchen
1. Mainely Lobster & Seafood
Mainely Lobster & Seafood is a spot where locals and visitors cross paths, drawn in by the unmistakable aroma of fresh seafood. Set on Military Turnpike, this place has the easy charm of a roadside favorite, where you can expect friendliness with every order.
The lobster roll here is something of a legend—soft, pillowy bread cradling sweet, cold lobster, dressed just enough to let the meat shine. For something warm and hearty, I’ve found the clam chowder to be a consistent crowd-pleaser, creamy but light enough to let the briny flavors lead.
It’s the kind of place where seafood tastes like it was plucked from the ocean that morning. Order the lobster roll or scallop plate if you want the best taste of Plattsburgh’s seafood scene.
2. Castaway On The Bay
Castaway On The Bay sits right at the edge of the water, blending relaxed lakeside views with a menu that brings out the best in local seafood. It’s the kind of place where summer afternoons slip by over plates of crisp fried fish and easy conversation.
What sets Castaway apart is its easygoing atmosphere. I remember unwinding here with friends, each bite of shrimp basket matched by that gentle breeze off the bay. It’s the local spot people mention when they talk about authentic Plattsburgh seafood.
Try the fish and chips or shrimp basket—both perfect examples of the kitchen’s knack for light batter and always-fresh ingredients. Castaway on the Bay has mastered the art of unpretentious, satisfying seafood.
3. Irises Cafe and Wine Bar
Irises Cafe and Wine Bar is tucked in the heart of downtown, with an appeal that never feels forced. The vibe is a blend of bistro cool and neighborhood comfort, and the aroma of scratch-cooked seafood always draws me in. It’s a spot I duck into when I want a meal that feels both special and relaxed.
Irises is not just about seafood, but the kitchen shines with dishes that emphasize freshness and creativity. I still remember a delicate seared salmon that managed to be both crisp and tender—a rare balance done just right here.
The pan-seared salmon and seafood pastas stand out for their clean flavors and thoughtful presentation. Every plate reminds you why Irises has earned its devoted following in Plattsburgh.
4. Naked Turtle
Naked Turtle sits right on Lake Champlain, boasting waterfront views that can turn even a quick meal into an occasion. This is where I once lingered over dinner, soaking up the sunset while the marina bustled below—Plattsburgh’s answer to casual lakeside dining with a lively twist.
The menu covers a solid range, but seafood’s the obvious draw. Naked Turtle’s take on grilled fish and classic lake-shore fare is all about bold, unfussy flavors that pair perfectly with the breezy vibe.
The grilled salmon and shrimp skewers are favorites of mine. Both capture that fresh, summer-on-the-water taste that keeps diners coming back. Naked Turtle makes lakeside seafood feel effortless and memorable.
5. Butcher Block Restaurant
Butcher Block Restaurant blends classic steakhouse charm with a quietly impressive seafood lineup. When I’m after a meal with a touch of elegance but none of the fuss, this place is at the top of my list. The soft lighting and polished service set just the right tone for a relaxing evening.
What gives Butcher Block its edge is the attention to detail in every dish, especially when it comes to the fish and shellfish. There’s a clear pride in getting the basics right, from the first bite to the last.
The broiled haddock and baked stuffed shrimp are consistent favorites. Both highlight the kitchen’s ability to keep seafood simple, fresh, and full of flavor, all while letting quality ingredients speak for themselves.
6. Latitude 44 Bistro
Latitude 44 Bistro manages to balance warmth and sophistication, making it a go-to for seafood with a touch of flair. With its polished but welcoming dining room, I felt instantly at ease—whether perched at the bar or outside on the patio. The menu rewards curiosity, leaning into fresh ingredients and unexpected touches.
What keeps Latitude 44 memorable is attention to detail. I still remember a dinner here that started with a perfectly cooked piece of fish, the kind that makes you pause a beat after the first bite. Every dish arrives with care and just the right amount of imagination.
The crab-stuffed haddock and seafood risotto always stand out. Both show off the kitchen’s knack for elevating classics without overcomplicating things. Here, seafood always feels like a special occasion, no matter what day it is.
7. Yama Sushi
Yama Sushi offers a fresh spin on Plattsburgh’s seafood scene, serving Japanese flavors in a relaxed, inviting setting. When I’m craving something lighter but bold, I find myself at a table here, watching rolls and sashimi pass by in an endless, colorful parade.
Consistency and quality win the day at Yama Sushi. From the first bite of salmon nigiri, it’s clear that attention goes into every piece of fish, making even a quick lunch feel like a treat.
The tuna roll and house special sashimi platter deserve their reputation. Both highlight the clean, delicate flavors Yama Sushi does best. This is where you go when the craving for truly fresh seafood won’t wait.
8. Happy Pike Ice Cream & Snack Bar
Happy Pike Ice Cream & Snack Bar is where childhood summers and classic lakefront snacks come together. Nestled on Lake Champlain, it’s as much about the view as what’s on your plate. I stopped in on a sunny afternoon and found the patio buzzing with families who knew a thing or two about good eats by the water.
This spot stands out for its casual, unpretentious fare. While ice cream draws a crowd, don’t overlook the fresh seafood baskets coming out of the kitchen. There’s something about enjoying crispy fish or shrimp with a side of lake breeze that just works.
The fried fish sandwich or shrimp basket make a case for classic comfort food done right. Happy Pike nails the balance between nostalgia and quality in every bite.
9. Shanty On The Shore
Shanty On The Shore brings an old-school charm to Burlington’s waterfront, just a scenic drive from Plattsburgh. There’s a laid-back energy here—a blend of nautical spirit and local tradition—that invites you to slow down and enjoy the view. I once settled into a table facing the lake, and time seemed to move differently as boats drifted by.
The menu takes seafood seriously, favoring freshness over flash. Shanty is known for its raw bar, but even if you’re not a purist, dishes like broiled haddock and classic clam chowder make a strong impression. The flavors always feel true to the setting: simple, vibrant, and never overdone.
The broiled haddock or seafood stew is a safe bet for anyone seeking honest, well-prepared seafood. For relaxed lakeside dining, Shanty is a classic that lives up to its reputation.
10. Bleu Northeast Kitchen
Bleu Northeast Kitchen, tucked into Burlington, brings a refined touch to Northeast seafood, just a short hop from Plattsburgh. The first time I dined here, I was drawn in by the open, modern feel and left remembering the way each dish felt artfully assembled yet never fussy.
The kitchen here shines with ingredients plucked straight from local waters and farms. It’s a place where flavors speak for themselves, enhanced by thoughtful technique and a creative spirit that remains true to the region.
The pan-seared lake fish and smoked trout chowder always linger on my mind. Both are clear showcases of Bleu’s commitment to freshness and elegant simplicity, making this an essential stop for anyone seeking local seafood with a polished edge.
More Things to Try in Plattsburgh, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Plattsburgh, NY?
Some of the top picks include Mainely Lobster & Seafood, Latitude 44 Bistro, and Butcher Block Restaurant. Each brings its own character to the table, whether you’re after classic lobster rolls or elevated bistro favorites.
Do Plattsburgh seafood restaurants offer fresh, locally-sourced fish?
Yes, many local restaurants prioritize fresh and, when possible, locally-sourced fish and shellfish. Ask your server about the day’s catch or regional specialties for the freshest options.
Where can I get seafood with a lakeside view near Plattsburgh?
Check out Naked Turtle or Castaway On The Bay, both offering that perfect combination of water views and relaxed seafood dining.
Are there vegetarian or family-friendly options at seafood spots in Plattsburgh?
Most seafood restaurants in Plattsburgh also feature vegetarian choices and kid-friendly meals, so everyone in your group can find something they enjoy.
What seafood dish should I try if I’ve never visited before?
Start with a classic lobster roll or a platter of fresh haddock. Both are Plattsburgh staples and showcase the region’s flavor and style.