Finding fresh, satisfying seafood in Red Oaks Mill, NY feels like uncovering a local secret—and once you know where to look, you’ll wonder why you ever settled for soggy fish or bland shrimp. My own hunt for the area’s best plates started on a chilly night craving something both comforting and memorable. One forkful of perfectly grilled salmon at an unassuming spot turned that simple evening into a mission: explore every menu, talk to regulars, and spotlight the places that get seafood right.
If you’re searching for serious seafood—think tender crab, crisp fish, and shrimp cooked just so—you’re in good hands. Consider this your guide to the best seafood in Red Oaks Mill and nearby restaurants where the flavors range from classic East Coast charm to bold, creative takes on old favorites. Whether it’s a splurge meal or a quick bite, you’ll find your new go-to. Curious yet? Let’s dive into the best seafood haunts around, each with its own story to tell.
Where to find the best seafood in Red Oaks Mill, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Red Oaks Mill, NY:
- Bonefish Grill – Closed
- Red Lobster
- Tasty Crab House
- Joe Willy S Fish
- Mariners on the Hudson
- Tammy Honeyman
- Eveready Diner
- Aladias Crab Cravings
- Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
- Billy Joe’s Ribworks
1. Bonefish Grill – Closed
Bonefish Grill may have closed its doors at the Red Oaks Mill location, but many locals still reminisce about their signature offerings. Tucked along South Road, this spot earned a reputation for delivering thoughtfully cooked seafood that felt both approachable and special. I remember slipping in after work for a plate of their pan-seared salmon, always paired with crisp seasonal veggies.
What set Bonefish Grill apart was their dedication to freshness and flavor. The menu offered choices like delicate tilapia and fire-grilled shrimp, each seasoned to perfection—never bland and never overworked. For dinner, the Bang Bang Shrimp was the go-to appetizer, thanks to its zesty sauce and light, crunchy coating.
If you ever find a menu from their heyday, you’ll spot a commitment to fresh seafood, expertly prepared and perfectly portioned.
2. Red Lobster
Red Lobster on South Road manages to balance nostalgic charm with a consistent lineup of crowd-pleasing seafood. It’s the kind of place where you want to linger a little longer, thanks to the bustling dining room and those famous Cheddar Bay Biscuits. My last visit was a lunch with friends, and even the pickiest eaters found something to savor.
The menu leans on familiar favorites done well. The Wood-Grilled Atlantic Salmon is a standout—juicy, flaky, and paired with sides that complement without stealing the show. If you’re in the mood to share, the Seaside Shrimp Trio covers all the bases, offering a little fried, a little broiled, and a lot of flavor.
Red Lobster’s appeal lies in its steady reliability. You walk in knowing what to expect, and almost always leave with a smile—and usually leftovers.
3. Tasty Crab House
(845) 454-2850Call
Tasty Crab House brings lively, hands-on seafood boils to South Road with a splash of southern flair. My first trip here felt like a mini celebration—you can’t help but get a little messy, and that’s part of the fun. Cracking open a crab leg while trading stories with friends makes time slow down in the best way.
The draw here is clear: build-your-own seafood combos with generous sauces packed with flavor. Choose your favorite seafood, pick the heat, and don’t shy away from their signature garlic butter. Portions lean hearty, so bring your appetite or a buddy for sharing.
If you’re looking for a meal with personality, try the snow crab clusters or shrimp boil. Both are cooked just right, holding onto sweet seafood flavor even under all that spice.
4. Joe Willy S Fish
Joe Willy S Fish, tucked into Westside Plaza, has the feel of a comfortable neighborhood spot where the seafood gets top billing. My visit left me pleasantly surprised—no pretenses, just genuine effort in every dish. The casual setting invites you to relax and focus on what matters: what’s on the plate.
The kitchen here knows how to handle classics. The standout? Lightly battered fish and chips—golden, crisp, and tender. It’s a dish that proves quality matters more than gimmicks. Portions are generous, so come hungry or ready to share.
If you want a little variety, the seafood platter is the way to go. There’s enough for everyone to have a taste, and each bite reflects their knack for bold, satisfying flavors.
5. Mariners on the Hudson
(845) 691-6011Call
Mariners on the Hudson pairs stunning river views with a seafood menu that draws both locals and visitors. Perched right on the water, it’s my go-to spot when I want dinner with a show—watching boats glide past as the sun drops behind the bridges is hard to top. Even the drive over feels like the start of something special.
Here, freshness is front and center. The kitchen turns out dishes like grilled salmon that arrives flaky and warm over well-seasoned vegetables. Their seafood risotto stands out, creamy without being heavy and packed with tender shrimp and delicate scallops.
Settle in on the deck with a good friend, let the breeze roll in, and you’ll find the meals at Mariners sit right at the intersection of comfort and scenery.
6. Tammy Honeyman
(845) 236-2700Call
Tammy Honeyman might fly under the radar, but to locals, it’s a quiet gem for seafood lovers along Route 9W. Stepping inside, I noticed the inviting, no-fuss ambiance and a chalkboard of daily specials—always a good sign in a seafood place. There’s a cozy comfort to the way Tammy Honeyman does things, letting quality and taste lead the way.
The highlight is their fresh fish of the day, cooked simply and served with just enough seasoning to let the natural flavors shine. I still think about the flaky cod I enjoyed here, served with bright vegetables and a hint of lemon. Portions are generous, so there’s enough to enjoy without feeling rushed.
It’s the sort of place where good food and easy hospitality come together seamlessly.
7. Eveready Diner
Eveready Diner isn’t your average retro pit stop. It blends classic diner comfort with a surprisingly robust seafood menu, perfect for late-night cravings or family weekends. My most recent visit had me settling into a shiny booth, greeted by the hum of friendly conversation and a menu thick with tempting choices.
The seafood section is impressively diverse, but the broiled haddock is the star. Lightly seasoned and cooked just right, it delivers that simple, satisfying flavor diner fans expect. For a heartier pick, the seafood platter serves up a medley—think plump shrimp and tender fish servings, perfect for sharing.
Whether you’re after nostalgia or just a well-cooked meal, Eveready Diner manages to feel timeless while offering something real for seafood lovers.
8. Aladias Crab Cravings
(845) 419-9175Call
Aladias Crab Cravings brings an inventive edge to seafood, putting Wallkill on the map for anyone obsessed with rich, flavorful shellfish. My visit happened on a whim during a road trip, but by the time I’d tackled a pile of crab legs, I was hooked. It’s the sort of place where you don’t need much of a plan—just a big appetite.
The focus here is, of course, on crab in all its glorious forms. The signature boil lets you pick your level of spice, and every bite packs both heat and savory depth. Garlic butter, in particular, elevates the crabs to new heights without overwhelming the freshness.
If you’re after a feast, go for the crab leg platter. It’s messy, abundant, and deeply satisfying from first bite to last.
9. Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
Gadaleto’s Seafood Market, just off Main Street in New Paltz, feels like a well-kept local secret. It’s more than a place to buy fresh fish—though that part alone is well worth the trip. On my last visit, the staff was quick with recommendations, sending me home with a fillet so fresh it barely needed seasoning.
What makes Gadaleto’s shine is their commitment to quality and variety. The market brims with options, from salmon to local catch, and it’s impossible to leave uninspired. Their dine-in menu offers gems like the grilled tuna steak, seared outside and silk-smooth inside—true to the fish’s natural flavor.
Whether you’re stocking your kitchen or sitting for a quick meal, Gadaleto’s delivers on both freshness and expertise every time.
10. Billy Joe’s Ribworks
Billy Joe’s Ribworks, perched on the Newburgh waterfront, is best known for smoky barbecue, but the seafood options here are far from an afterthought. On a sunny afternoon, I snagged a riverside table and was swept in by the lively atmosphere—think live music, laughter, and the buzz of a full house.
If you’re in the mood for surf instead of turf, the grilled salmon is a pleasant surprise. Perfectly cooked, with a subtle char that lets the natural flavors shine, it’s a dish that more than holds its own among the smoky classics. The waterfront setting doesn’t hurt either—fresh air pairs well with fresh fish.
For a group, the seafood appetizer sampler is ideal. It offers enough variety to keep everyone reaching for just one more bite.
More Things to Try in Red Oaks Mill, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants near Red Oaks Mill?
Several reliable options stand out: Red Lobster for classic favorites, Tasty Crab House if you like spicy boils, and Gadaleto’s Seafood Market for incredibly fresh and simple dishes. Mariners on the Hudson is a top pick for waterfront dining.
Do any seafood places in the area offer takeout or delivery?
Yes, many do. Red Lobster, Tasty Crab House, and Joe Willy S Fish all offer takeout, making it easy to enjoy seafood at home. Some local spots may also deliver through third-party apps.
Where can I find fresh, high-quality seafood to cook at home?
Gadaleto’s Seafood Market in New Paltz is your best bet. They carry a wide selection of fresh fish and shellfish, and the staff is happy to help with tips or recipes.
Are there good options for groups or families?
Absolutely. Red Lobster and Eveready Diner both serve generous portions, and their menus cater to a wide range of tastes and ages. Mariners on the Hudson is great for family gatherings when you want a memorable view with your meal.
What seafood dishes are popular in Red Oaks Mill restaurants?
You’ll find everything from grilled salmon and cod to hearty seafood platters and customizable seafood boils. Many places pride themselves on classic flavors and simple preparation to highlight freshness.
