Finding great seafood in Ridge, NY feels a bit like searching for hidden treasure, but it’s far less risky and much tastier. I spent more than a few evenings dodging soggy fries and bland fillets before finally cracking the code to Ridge’s standout seafood scene. Good news: you don’t need to wade through a sea of mediocrity. From cozy markets serving the day’s best catch to casual joints where shrimp really means shrimp, Ridge has its own flavor-packed journey for anyone who craves quality seafood.
If you prefer snappy fish tacos, a robust shellfish stew, or fried calamari with just the right crunch, Ridge keeps its secrets tucked away in plain sight. Freshness is the rule, not the exception. I’m about to open the menu, so to speak, and show you where satisfaction consistently tops the menu. Keep reading to discover local spots where the only thing more abundant than the variety is the conversation about what’s for dinner.
Where to find the best seafood in Ridge, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Ridge, NY:
- Oceans 5 Seafood Market and Eatery
- Atlantic Seafood Fish Market
- Papa Francescos Restaurant And Pizzeria
- PJ Lobster House
- WAVE Seafood Kitchen
- Citi Island Seafood
- California Fish and Chips
- The Monster Crab
- Popei’s Clam Bar
- Island Fish
1. Oceans 5 Seafood Market and Eatery
Oceans 5 Seafood Market and Eatery blends a refined dining experience with a top-notch seafood market, less than a mile from Long Island Sound. The dual nature of this spot means you can pick up fresh fillets for home or sit down for a meal prepared by their seasoned chef. Every plate strikes a balance between comfort and culinary skill.
When I stopped in, I was struck by the staff’s knowledge and the subtle flavors in their classic grilled salmon. Their lobster roll boasts plump, sweet chunks of lobster on a perfectly toasted bun—a can’t-miss option if you want something simply satisfying. The raw bar is also impressive, with oysters that taste like the ocean itself. Oceans 5 is ideal for anyone seeking freshness with a bit of elegance.
2. Atlantic Seafood Fish Market
(631) 878-8406Call
Atlantic Seafood Fish Market offers genuine simplicity—fresh catches and classic preparations right in Center Moriches. There’s no pretense here, just a solid market and straightforward service that make the process of taking home seafood refreshingly easy. The sea-to-counter freshness speaks for itself.
During my visit, I was welcomed with helpful suggestions and a display case that promises dinner success. Their flounder fillet delivers pure, delicate flavor, while the stuffed sole is comfort at its best. The clam chowder is hearty and not overly creamy, making it a staple for any chilly evening.
Atlantic Seafood Fish Market is your spot if you appreciate consistency and old-school charm. The flavors here are honest, with nothing masking the quality of their seafood.
3. Papa Francescos Restaurant And Pizzeria
(631) 849-6622Call
Papa Francescos Restaurant And Pizzeria offers more than classic Italian comfort food—it surprises with a hidden talent for seafood. This is the kind of local spot where the pizza oven works overtime, but the kitchen also shines with seafood pasta dishes and shrimp specials.
On my last visit, the shrimp fra diavolo was a standout. The sauce had a gentle kick and the shrimp were tender, not rubbery, paired with perfectly al dente pasta. The calamari was light, crispy, and easy to finish.
This spot stands out for warm, fast service and generous portions. Papa Francescos is for anyone who wants approachable, satisfying seafood wrapped in a cozy, family-run vibe.
4. PJ Lobster House
PJ Lobster House brings the coastal vibe of Port Jefferson right to your plate, with a mix of market-fresh seafood and classic sit-down meals. It’s the sort of place where both locals and day-trippers fill the tables for fresh catches and relaxed conversation. The live lobster tank is always the star attraction, promising the freshest dish possible.
Every visit here feels like a treat. I tried their lobster, prepared simply with drawn butter—each bite sweet, tender, and undeniably fresh. Their baked clams and fluke fillet are also memorable, offering vibrant flavors without heavy sauces.
With a casual, laid-back atmosphere and attentive staff, PJ Lobster House is perfect for savoring seafood at its most straightforward and satisfying.
5. WAVE Seafood Kitchen
WAVE Seafood Kitchen sits right by the Long Island Sound, serving views that compete with the menu for your attention. The restaurant stands out for its upscale approach and commitment to fresh, local ingredients. The scene is lively—perfect for both relaxed brunches and memorable dinners.
On my visit, the roasted local fluke was a highlight. It was fresh, flaky, and paired with vibrant vegetables that truly tasted farm-to-table. Their seafood paella offered a taste of the ocean, inventive but not overcomplicated.
If you value creative twists on classics and a waterview to match, WAVE delivers. It’s a spot where the menu changes with the seasons, keeping each meal distinct and full of flavor.
6. Citi Island Seafood
(631) 772-7227Call
Citi Island Seafood offers a fresh, laid-back take on classic seafood, tucked away in Shirley. This spot leans into no-fuss counter service but surprises with quality that competes with bigger-name restaurants. Every dish feels thoughtfully assembled, from the batter on the fish to the brightness of the sides.
I tried their grilled salmon, which arrived perfectly moist and seasoned just right—nothing to cover up, just real flavor. The crab cakes here are a must: packed with crab, light on filler, and pan-seared for just the right crust.
Citi Island Seafood is great for those craving authentic taste without a long wait. Quick, friendly service and generous portions seal the deal for anyone passing through or calling Shirley home.
7. California Fish and Chips
(631) 731-3474Call
California Fish and Chips has made a name for itself in Mastic Beach by serving up classics with care. The menu might seem simple, but the execution is what makes this spot different. Everything arrives crisp, golden, and never greasy, showing that technique sets them apart.
Stopping in for lunch, I was impressed by their signature fish and chips. The fish was flaky with a perfectly crunchy coating, and the fries held up from first bite to last. The shrimp platter is another hit—big, juicy shrimp that deliver real flavor with each bite.
This is your go-to for comfort food done right, perfect for anyone who wants consistent quality and a taste of seaside tradition.
8. The Monster Crab
The Monster Crab in Holtsville brings a bold, hands-on seafood experience that’s all about messy, memorable meals. They specialize in seafood boils brimming with crab, shrimp, and clams, tossed in savory seasonings that you’ll remember long after your last bite.
On my visit, I dove into a crab boil with corn and potatoes—the seasoning was vibrant, just spicy enough, and let each ingredient shine. The snow crab legs here are sweet and satisfying, perfect for anyone craving a feast.
This is your place if you’re after flavor-packed sharing plates and casual, lively fun. Wear the bib, get your hands dirty, and enjoy shellfish how it was meant to be eaten.
9. Popei’s Clam Bar
Popei’s Clam Bar in Coram has earned its stripes after decades on the scene, serving seafood that brings together loyal regulars and first-timers. The menu overflows with variety, from classic clams to surprises like broiled fish platters. There’s always something to suit a craving, no matter how specific.
What stood out to me is their homemade touch—the clam chowder is rich without being heavy, and the grilled fish tastes fresh off the dock. For something hearty, the seafood combo platter is a feast, giving you a tour of the fryers and grill in one go.
Popei’s keeps things cheerful and casual, making it the kind of place that delivers seafood with a familiar neighborhood feel.
10. Island Fish
Island Fish in Farmingville offers a welcoming, unfussy seafood stop for anyone after honest flavors and generous portions. They combine a market’s freshness with the convenience of a casual counter eatery, making it just as easy to bring home dinner as to dine in.
I sampled their baked cod, which arrived flaky and full of flavor—a true highlight for a quick lunch. The fish fry is consistently crisp, without any heavy batter weighing it down, and the seasonal specials always bring something interesting to the board.
Island Fish is for those who value a simple, satisfying seafood fix without pretense. Quick service, fair prices, and a commitment to freshness keep locals coming back.
More Things to Try in Ridge, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants near Ridge, NY?
Top picks include Oceans 5 Seafood Market and Eatery, Atlantic Seafood Fish Market, and PJ Lobster House. Each offers a unique experience but shares a commitment to quality and freshness.
Can I find halal or vegetarian seafood options in Ridge, NY?
Some spots like Oceans 5 and Papa Francescos offer vegetarian seafood dishes. It’s best to call ahead to confirm current halal offerings before dining.
Where can I buy fresh seafood to cook at home?
Check out Atlantic Seafood Fish Market and Island Fish. Both have fresh counters with plenty of variety, perfect for home cooks.
Are there family-friendly seafood restaurants in Ridge, NY?
Absolutely. Places like Papa Francescos and Popei’s Clam Bar offer casual atmospheres and menus that appeal to all ages.
What dishes do locals recommend?
Lobster rolls at Oceans 5, clam chowder from Popei’s Clam Bar, and stuffed sole at Atlantic Seafood Fish Market are popular go-tos among regulars.
Do any Ridge seafood spots offer takeout or delivery?
Many listed restaurants have strong takeout options. Citi Island Seafood and Island Fish are known for reliable, quick service.
