The hunt for exceptional seafood in Roslyn Heights, NY can feel like chasing a secret tide. This charming pocket of Long Island isn’t the sort of place where neon lobster signs shout for your attention on every corner, but once you look closer, you’ll notice there’s a quiet bustle behind the doors of local gems. I’ve spent more than one lazy weekend dipping into these spots—sometimes so caught up in the flavor that conversation would drift away, replaced by that contented silence only outstanding seafood can inspire.
If you’ve been scrolling through endless reviews, unsure where to start or what’s truly fresh, you’re in the right place. This guide is built from both taste and curiosity, steering you toward the most reliable menus, unforgettable bites, and hidden favorites—all offering only halal-friendly, permissible options. Whether you crave delicate crudo, crackling fried fish, or gently seasoned grilled platters, there’s a seat reserved for you somewhere on this list. Get ready to discover where to find the real standouts, bite after bite.
Where to find the best seafood in Roslyn Heights, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Roslyn Heights, NY:
- Roslyn Seafood Gourmet
- Harbor Seafood
- Atlas New World Bistro
- Gera’s Cakes
- Sea Bar
- Reede Intl Seafood Corp
- Singleton Seafood Shack
- Vincents Clam Bar
- Carlyle Seafood Shack
- Blue Chip Fish & Chips
1. Roslyn Seafood Gourmet
(516) 484-7944Call
Roslyn Seafood Gourmet sits quietly off Willis Ave, but don’t let the modest storefront fool you. Step inside and you’re greeted by a spotless counter gleaming with today’s catch—fresh, shimmering, and full of promise. My own visit turned a routine dinner into a mini celebration with friends, thanks to flavors that felt both classic and bright.
What sets this spot apart is its genuine neighborhood vibe and the care shown in every fillet or shellfish order. The grilled salmon, with its light char and burst of lemon, became my go-to—simple, but undeniably well-prepared. Their seafood platters offer a variety that pleases both new explorers and longtime seafood fans.
If you’re looking to bring the sea home, their market selection tempts with both value and quality. It’s hard to leave without a plan for your next visit.
2. Harbor Seafood
Harbor Seafood, tucked on Lakeville Road, is one of those places where quality whispers rather than shouts. The glow from the display case hints at the array of fresh, responsibly sourced seafood inside. I remember the subtle excitement of choosing from shellfish caught just hours earlier—sometimes a rare thrill outside coastal towns.
What makes Harbor Seafood unique is its reliable balance of variety and freshness. The service is direct and knowledgeable, with staff quick to guide you toward the best of the day. Their steamed shrimp is a must—tender, juicy, and perfectly seasoned. The grilled branzino also stands out, expertly cooked until smoky and crisp.
Whether you’re picking up for dinner or planning a special feast, this is a spot where satisfaction comes easy and quality is in every bite.
3. Atlas New World Bistro
Atlas New World Bistro feels like a passport in restaurant form, nestled within the Roslyn Hotel. The ambiance strikes a luxe note, but it’s the inventive plates that spark curiosity. My visit here started with soft jazz, a cozy booth, and servers who treated each dish as a work of art. It’s a place where dinner lingers, in all the right ways.
Atlas stands out for fusion seafood dishes that highlight both global flair and top-notch ingredients. The miso-glazed sea bass caught my attention, perfectly balanced between sweet and savory. For something refreshing, try the citrus-marinated crudo; it’s vibrant and truly showcases how the kitchen mixes tradition with imagination.
Dine here to take your taste buds traveling without ever leaving Roslyn Heights.
4. Gera’s Cakes
(516) 307-9195Call
Gera’s Cakes delivers far more than the name hints at—this quaint Mineola spot is where authentic Peruvian flavors steal the spotlight. I once wandered in, tempted by the aroma drifting from the kitchen, and left convinced that comfort food has a global accent here.
The charm lies in their friendly approach and bold, home-style dishes. The Peruvian seafood ceviche is a highlight, bursting with citrus and fresh herbs. For a satisfying meal, try the pescado a lo macho—a vibrant medley of fish and seafood simmered in a savory sauce that pairs perfectly with white rice.
Gera’s Cakes strikes a balance between hearty fare and delicate flavors, giving local seafood a unique twist that’s both inviting and memorable.
5. Sea Bar
Sea Bar in Great Neck Plaza brings a light, modern take to seafood dining, with a vibe that’s at once relaxed and upbeat. When the urge for fresh seafood hit, I found myself here, wooed by the energy of an open kitchen and the crisp, sea-scented air drifting from each plate.
The main attraction is freshness, showcased in every dish. The whole roasted branzino stands out—a simple presentation that lets clean, naturally sweet flavors shine. I’d also suggest the seafood risotto, rich with perfectly cooked shellfish and just the right hint of herbs.
Sea Bar is for anyone craving balanced, unfussy dishes that put the spotlight on quality ingredients and expert execution.
6. Reede Intl Seafood Corp
(516) 365-0265Call
Reede Intl Seafood Corp operates under the radar, nestled in a quiet Roslyn neighborhood and run with a straightforward, no-frills style. My first visit felt almost like being let in on a local secret—just a phone call and a quick dash with cash in hand.
This spot is known for its direct-from-market freshness. The selection is small but curated, often featuring pristine fillets and shellfish with a just-caught quality. The flounder fillets here are especially tender and flake apart beautifully when cooked at home. If you enjoy classic preparations, their wild-caught shrimp is subtly sweet and shines whether grilled or pan-sautéed.
Reede Intl is ideal for those who prefer to choose top-tier seafood and put their own spin on it in the kitchen.
7. Singleton Seafood Shack
(516) 609-0300Call
Singleton Seafood Shack sits by the water, offering up Long Island’s sun-and-salt air charm in every bite. It’s the kind of place where casual meets quality, and picnic tables invite you to slow down. My last visit was a lazy afternoon that turned into an impromptu seafood feast, thanks to welcoming staff and plates packed with flavor.
This is a shack in name but not in standards. The grilled fish tacos are crisp, light, and loaded with fresh slaw—a perfect bite of summer. The steamed littleneck clams are full of natural sweetness, drawing regulars with their subtle brininess.
If you crave unfussy, well-executed seafood where the ingredients do most of the work, Singleton shines brightest.
8. Vincents Clam Bar
(516) 279-4477Call
Vincents Clam Bar has cultivated a loyal following near Carle Place, winning over locals with hearty portions and a bustling, unpretentious vibe. My meal there kicked off with laughter around a big table—a family-style spot where plates and stories are meant to be shared.
This spot stands out by blending classic seafood with approachable, crowd-pleasing recipes. The linguine with white clam sauce is the star—al dente pasta tangled with fresh clams and a warm, garlicky broth that never felt heavy. The grilled calamari also deserves a mention, offering smoky, tender slices that hint at summer by the shore.
Whether for a casual night or a celebratory meal, Vincents knows how to turn seafood into pure comfort without fuss.
9. Carlyle Seafood Shack
(516) 399-2207Call
Carlyle Seafood Shack in Sea Cliff feels like a breezy getaway tucked just off the main streets. I first stopped in after a beach afternoon, drawn to the friendly chatter drifting out the door. The vibe is easygoing but the kitchen turns out food that’s anything but ordinary.
What makes Carlyle stand out is its focus on bright flavors and unfussy presentation. The grilled mahi-mahi is a reliable favorite—mild, flaky, and paired with seasonal vegetables that taste sun-ripened and fresh. If you’re after comfort, the seafood chowder is brimming with chunks of fish and just enough herbs to leave you lingering over every spoonful.
Carlyle Seafood Shack brings together warmth, freshness, and the kind of simple excellence seafood fans hunt for again and again.
10. Blue Chip Fish & Chips
(516) 742-2240Call
Blue Chip Fish & Chips on Jericho Turnpike proves that good things come wrapped in paper. My first visit was spontaneous, yet the golden aroma from behind the counter was reason enough to stay. This spot specializes in nostalgic, old-school comfort—generous portions, crisp batter, and a menu that sticks to what works.
Blue Chip stands out by keeping it simple and letting freshness do the talking. The classic fish and chips is the undisputed highlight: lightly battered, flaky white fish served with hot, salty fries. The fried shrimp plate deserves a nod too, cooked just right for a satisfying crunch and sweet finish.
It’s a place for no-nonsense, satisfying seafood, perfect for those times when only fried comfort will do.
More Things to Try in Roslyn Heights, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood restaurants in Roslyn Heights are best for takeout?
Several local spots shine for takeout, including Roslyn Seafood Gourmet for fresh fillets and platters, and Blue Chip Fish & Chips for their reliably crisp fried fare. Most offer quick service and convenient packaging, keeping your meal as fresh at home as it is at the counter.
Are there halal-friendly seafood options in Roslyn Heights?
Yes, many seafood restaurants in and around Roslyn Heights offer halal-friendly choices. Dishes like grilled fish, shrimp, and seafood risotto are typically safe picks. If you’re ordering out, you can always confirm preparations by giving the restaurant a call.
Where can I find the freshest seafood in Roslyn Heights, NY?
Roslyn Seafood Gourmet and Reede Intl Seafood Corp both have a reputation for top-quality daily selections. Stop by early for the best catch and to see what’s new on ice.
What are some signature seafood dishes to try in Roslyn Heights?
Don’t miss house specials like the grilled salmon at Roslyn Seafood Gourmet, the clams at Vincents Clam Bar, and mahi-mahi at Carlyle Seafood Shack. Each of these highlights the kitchen’s skill and the ingredient’s natural flavor.
Do seafood restaurants in Roslyn Heights offer gluten-free options?
Many spots have naturally gluten-free selections like grilled fish, salads, and steamed shellfish. It’s always smart to double-check with staff, as menus change and preparations vary.
