Rye, NY has a knack for making seafood feel like a celebration. One visit here and you’ll realize this town treats the ocean’s bounty with respect, flavor, and just the right amount of flair. Imagine walking along Purchase Street as the salty air tempts you to step inside a bistro or two, each one promising a new twist on classic dishes. Rye’s seafood scene doesn’t shout for attention, but it’s the sort you remember long after the last bite.
I’ve spent afternoons getting lost in hidden gems tucked behind unassuming facades. A quiet oyster bar where the shucking is a small performance, a family-run spot where the clams recall summers spent at the shore. With every meal, I found something new to appreciate—a clever sauce, a fresh catch, or just good conversation with locals at the next table. If you’re ready to chart your own course through the best seafood spots in Rye, you’re in the right harbor. The list ahead is your map.
Where to find the best seafood in Rye, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Rye, NY:
- Ruby’s Oyster Bar & Bistro
- Ocean Blue Prime
- Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant
- Averna Italian Steakhouse
- The Barley Beach House
- Morgans Fish House
- Belluscio’s Restaurant
- Kelly’s Sea Level
- Pier Restaurant & Tiki Bar
- Crab Shell
1. Ruby’s Oyster Bar & Bistro
Ruby’s Oyster Bar & Bistro draws you in with its Parisian flair and relaxed charm. Step inside and the ruby-red drapes, mosaic floor, and lively hum set the scene for a memorable meal. My favorite seat is at the zinc bar, where a dozen oysters offers a quick escape after a long week.
The seafood here feels like a celebration. The oysters are always fresh, but the seared scallops truly impress—delicate, perfectly caramelized, and paired with seasonal vegetables. For those leaning classic, the crisp calamari and tender shrimp cocktail never miss.
Ruby’s manages to strike a rare balance: upscale yet approachable, with food that’s as friendly as the service. This is the spot to savor Rye’s best shellfish.
2. Ocean Blue Prime
Ocean Blue Prime immediately impresses with its sleek, modern atmosphere and airy waterfront views. I found the elegant dining room a fitting stage for Chef Tony’s seafood creations—there’s a buzz in the air, whether you’re celebrating or just indulging.
The lobster tails here are a showstopper, arriving at the table plump and sweet with just the right touch of lemon butter. The Chilean sea bass is also a standout, pairing silky texture with bright seasonal vegetables for a dish that feels both refined and comforting.
Service is polished, but never stiff. The menu is confident, spotlighting seafood that speaks for itself. For anyone craving the best of Rye’s local catch, Ocean Blue Prime easily delivers an experience you’ll want to revisit.
3. Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant
Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant makes seafood feel like a summer festival right on the water. The open-air seating lets you savor the breeze as well as the view—sand between your toes is strongly encouraged. This is the spot for casual, sun-soaked meals where time slows down.
I’ve had some of my most lively dinners here, with platters of fried shrimp and fish sandwiches arriving to the table faster than the tide. The fish tacos are always a hit: fresh, crisp, and full of flavor, capturing the easygoing vibe of the pier.
Tiki Beach stands out for its relaxed atmosphere and unfussy, generous portions. Order the grilled catch of the day and watch the sunset—you’ll understand why this beachside gem is a local favorite.
4. Averna Italian Steakhouse
9143055330
Averna Italian Steakhouse blends classic Italian warmth with a refined seafood selection. The atmosphere is polished but never cold; it’s the kind of place where everyone seems to linger a little longer over dinner. I’ve enjoyed quiet evenings here with friends, where each course feels like a pleasant indulgence.
The seafood risotto stands out for its rich, balanced flavors—plump shrimp and tender calamari, all nestled in creamy rice. The grilled branzino, with its crispy skin and tender flakes, is a must for anyone craving something light yet deeply satisfying.
Averna’s approach is all about quality ingredients and classic technique. If you want to experience seafood inspired by Italian tradition, this is your table in Rye.
5. The Barley Beach House
The Barley Beach House feels like Rye’s answer to endless summer. Every table comes with a view of the water and the relaxed energy of beachfront dining. I love grabbing a spot on the patio as the sun sets, letting the sea breeze set the pace for the night.
It’s easy to see why locals keep coming back. The fish tacos are a crowd favorite—bright, tangy, and wrapped in warm tortillas. The miso salmon is another menu highlight, balancing sweet and savory notes with every bite. For a taste of something classic, the mussels never disappoint, served steaming and fragrant.
The Barley Beach House stands out for its easygoing vibe and comfort food done right. Come for the view, stay for the fresh catch.
6. Morgans Fish House
(914) 921-8190Call
Morgans Fish House is where seafood shines in a comforting, upscale setting. The casual elegance makes it an easy pick for both laid-back lunches and special dinners. I’ve wandered in on a weeknight and found the place buzzing—locals know this is where to go when cravings for shellfish hit.
The lobster bisque is velvety and rich, a perfect start on a chilly evening. If you’re in the mood for something with a touch of crunch, the cornmeal-crusted calamari is golden and satisfying. The seared scallops here are another highlight, their sweetness amplified by simple, thoughtful preparation.
Morgans Fish House stands out for its balanced mix of familiar favorites and clever specials. The menu is grounded in fresh ingredients and inviting flavors, making it a staple in Rye’s seafood lineup.
7. Belluscio’s Restaurant
(914) 967-5634Call
Belluscio’s Restaurant is that classic neighborhood spot where regulars are greeted by name. The mood is warm and unpretentious, with a menu that covers both timeless Italian comfort and well-crafted seafood. Family gatherings here stretch into the evening, thanks to generous portions and friendly service.
The seafood linguine is a standout—tender pasta twirled with shrimp, calamari, and a bright tomato sauce. If you’re looking for something lighter, the grilled salmon delivers well-seasoned flavor with a crisp edge. Belluscio’s also offers a rotating selection of fresh daily catches, letting the quality of the seafood shine.
Belluscio’s stands out for its inviting atmosphere and steadfast approach to tradition. It’s a top choice for those who want seafood with a side of nostalgia.
8. Kelly’s Sea Level
(914) 967-0868Call
Kelly’s Sea Level is one of Rye’s hidden gems—a laid-back spot with a loyal following and an easygoing vibe. This is where you go for simple seafood, cold drinks, and a sense of community you don’t find everywhere. On my last visit, laughter from the bar carried through the whole dining room.
The fried shrimp platter is legendary—crispy, never greasy, and served with a pile of hand-cut fries. The fish sandwich is another go-to, always fresh with a hint of lemon and just enough crunch.
Kelly’s stands out for making everyone feel like a local. It’s the place for unfussy seafood, plenty of character, and a relaxed lunch or dinner that never feels rushed.
9. Pier Restaurant & Tiki Bar
Pier Restaurant & Tiki Bar gives seafood a playful spin, right at the water’s edge. The open deck, lively crowd, and beachy drinks make every meal feel like a mini vacation. It’s the kind of place you wander into after a day at Playland and end up staying for sunset.
The grilled fish tacos here steal the show—light, zesty, and bursting with fresh flavors. For something even more laid-back, try the shrimp basket. Each bite is crisp, hot, and brimming with that salty-aired pier feeling.
Pier Restaurant & Tiki Bar stands out by making seafood fun and approachable. If you’re after casual bites and a lively setting, this hotspot more than delivers.
10. Crab Shell
Crab Shell brings a laid-back, nautical vibe to Stamford’s waterfront dining scene. The lively patio is perfect for soaking in harbor views while enjoying classic seafood favorites. It’s a spot I head to when I need a quick escape that doesn’t feel far from Rye.
The Maryland crab cakes are the true heroes here—golden, packed with flavor, and just the right hint of spice. The Alaskan king crab legs are also a solid pick, each one sweet and tender, ready for a dip in drawn butter.
Crab Shell stands out for its bustling atmosphere and honest, fresh seafood. Stop in for a casual lunch or dinner and you’ll see why this local haunt draws crowds all season long.
More Things to Try in Rye, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Rye, NY?
Some top picks include Ruby’s Oyster Bar & Bistro, Morgans Fish House, Ocean Blue Prime, and The Barley Beach House. These spots are known for their quality seafood, fresh ingredients, and inviting atmospheres.
Is it easy to find halal or vegetarian seafood options in Rye?
Many restaurants offer vegetarian-friendly menu items and can accommodate dietary requests. Always ask staff for guidance or menu details before ordering.
When is the best time to visit Rye for seafood dining?
Seafood menus in Rye shine year-round, but summer is especially lively with outdoor seating by the water and seasonal specials.
Do Rye seafood restaurants offer takeout or outdoor dining?
Yes, most seafood spots in Rye offer both takeout and outdoor seating, giving you plenty of flexibility whether you want to dine in, picnic at the beach, or enjoy a meal at home.
Are there any waterfront seafood restaurants in Rye?
Yes—the Barley Beach House, Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant, and Pier Restaurant & Tiki Bar all offer dining by the water, bringing those shorefront views right to your table.
