Seaford is a quiet patch of Long Island, but ask any local where to find the best seafood and you’ll get an earful. I remember walking along Merrick Road on a cool afternoon, trailing the salty breeze that always seems to hint at fresh oysters, buttery lobster, and crispy fried fish. This neighborhood knows seafood. It doesn’t put on airs—each spot seems to have earned its reputation the honest way, by dishing up food that makes you come back, usually with friends in tow.
Finding the best seafood in Seaford, NY isn’t about status or flash; it’s about a plate that surprises you or brings back a bold taste from childhood summers by the bay. If you crave the perfect shrimp cocktail or want to discover a tucked-away tavern with the friendliest shuckers, you’re in the right place. Every seafood joint here has a story, and sampling your way through them is the only way to uncover the real treasures. Let’s dig in.
Where to find the best seafood in Seaford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Seaford, NY:
- Crabby Amy’s
- The White Whale
- Gusto Divino Trattoria
- Lobster Shack
- Jackson Road House
- Bayview Tavern
- Runyon’s
- Crabby Amy’s Clam & Oyster Bar
1. Crabby Amy’s
Tucked away on Ocean Avenue, Crabby Amy’s looks unassuming from the outside. Step in and there’s a warmth that you don’t find everywhere—part cozy diner, part bustling seafood shack. On my first visit, I sat outdoors with a bowl of velvety clam chowder, watching neighbors catch up over baskets of crisp fish and golden fries. It felt like finding a secret spot only locals talk about.
Crabby Amy’s thrives on simplicity and quality. There’s no pretense, just fresh seafood prepared well. Try the broiled salmon if you want something hearty, or opt for their signature crab cakes—they’re packed, not with fillers, but with sweet crab and a hint of spice. The fried shrimp platter is another solid bet, always cooked just right.
2. The White Whale
The White Whale on Bayview Street is the kind of place that quietly impresses. My first visit began with a window seat overlooking the marina, which set the mood for seafood that’s equal parts classic and creative. There’s a nautical vibe here—relaxed, but you can tell every plate gets close attention.
Their grilled swordfish caught me off guard with its tender, meaty bite and subtle seasoning. It’s proof they know how to let the fish speak for itself. The seared scallops here are delicately charred and perfectly juicy, best paired with seasonal vegetables that always seem sourced nearby.
If you want something comforting, go for the shrimp scampi. The flavors are bright, garlicky, and distinctly coastal. This is where you linger long after the last bite, already plotting your return.
3. Gusto Divino Trattoria
Gusto Divino Trattoria blends the best of Italian traditions with Long Island’s love for seafood. I once found myself here on a rainy afternoon, drawn in by the aroma of garlic and olive oil that spills right out onto Sunrise Highway. The space feels lively, with a buzz from both regulars and newcomers.
The pasta here is reliably excellent, but the Frutti di Mare is a real showcase. It’s a bowl piled high with tender clams, shrimp, and calamari, all swirling in a tangy, herb-flecked tomato sauce. The grilled branzino stands out, arriving with crisp skin and a bright squeeze of lemon. That simplicity lets the freshness shine.
If you’re celebrating or just craving seafood with Italian flair, this is the move. Don’t skip their seafood risotto for a creamy, satisfying finish.
4. Lobster Shack
Lobster Shack on Merrick Road is impossible to miss—with the name, you know exactly what you’re walking into. Inside, it’s casual but inviting, the kind of spot where you roll up your sleeves and get cracking. My visit began with the aroma of melted butter and fresh lobster filling the air.
Lobster is clearly the star here. The classic lobster roll has generous chunks of sweet, perfectly cooked lobster on a toasted bun. It’s soft, a little warm, and comfortingly simple. The crab-stuffed flounder deserves a mention too, delicately baked to enhance the natural flavor of the fish without overpowering it.
There’s something relaxing about the unfussy, straightforward menu. If you want seafood the way it should be—fresh, flavorful, and satisfying—Lobster Shack is the place.
5. Jackson Road House
Jackson Road House feels like Seaford’s hidden anchor for a laid-back night out. Tucked along Bayview Street, its lively, no-fuss vibe makes every visit feel unhurried. I found myself here after a long week, greeted by friendly staff who treat regulars and first-timers alike.
The seafood here is always fresh, but the grilled tuna steak left a serious impression with its perfect char and silky center. If comfort is what you’re after, the baked cod delivers: flaky, mild, and topped with just enough herbs to keep each bite interesting. The menu shifts with what’s best in season, an approach that keeps regulars guessing and coming back.
For a crowd-pleaser, order the shrimp basket. It’s crisp, light, and generous—exactly what a roadside tavern should offer.
6. Bayview Tavern
(516) 809-6997Call
At Bayview Tavern, you get the kind of neighborhood spot where everyone’s a regular after just one meal. My best memory here was sitting by the window with a group of friends, the table full of laughter and plates stacked with seafood. There’s a casual energy that invites you to stay a while.
The fish tacos are a standout, each one bursting with flaky fish and crisp slaw, wrapped in fresh tortillas. Their baked salmon balances savory richness with a hint of lemon, showing off the kitchen’s respect for simple, well-prepared food. If you’re sharing, the seafood sampler is loaded and generous.
This is local dining at its best: unfussy, wallet-friendly, and reliably delicious seafood every time.
7. Runyon’s
Runyon’s pulls off a rare trick: it feels both like a lively bar and a welcoming seafood grill. I found myself nibbling popcorn at the bar while scanning a menu full of surprises. There’s a friendly din from softball teams wrapping up their night, but it never gets too loud to enjoy a good meal.
The clam pizetta is a must-try—a thin pita, baked crisp and layered with tender clams, briny and rich. You’ll also find creative seafood dishes like kung po squid: spicy, with an unusual twist that somehow just works. For something classic, their grilled salmon is consistently fresh and well-prepared.
It’s hard not to linger here. The booths are cozy, the seafood selection honestly impressive, and there’s enough variety to keep everyone happy.
8. Crabby Amy’s Clam & Oyster Bar
(516) 900-1395Call
Crabby Amy’s Clam & Oyster Bar is one of those rare finds where the freshest shellfish seem just an order away. My stop here was all about the raw bar—there’s nothing quite like a tray of icy cold clams and oysters, each one shucked right before your eyes and bursting with briny flavor.
What sets this spot apart is its focus on simplicity. The classic fresh oysters and little neck clams let the local waters shine. You’ll also find shrimp cocktail that’s bright, snappy, and never overdone. For those who prefer something warm, their Manhattan clam chowder has a peppery kick without overshadowing the sweet shellfish.
It’s a small place, with a big local following—easy to see why once you taste how fresh it all is.
More Things to Try in Seaford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Seaford, NY?
favorites include Crabby Amy’s, The White Whale, Lobster Shack, and Bayview Tavern. Each offers something a little different, from casual oyster bars to classic sit-down experiences.
Do Seaford seafood spots offer outdoor seating?
Yes, several places feature outdoor seating, especially during warmer months. Crabby Amy’s and The White Whale are popular for their relaxing patios.
Are there seafood restaurants suitable for families in Seaford?
Plenty of options are family-friendly. Lobster Shack and Runyon’s have laid-back atmospheres where kids and groups feel right at home.
Can I find vegetarian options at seafood restaurants in Seaford?
You’ll find vegetarian choices at several restaurants, especially at Gusto Divino Trattoria, which balances Italian seafood dishes with plenty of meat-free plates.
Is it necessary to make reservations at Seaford’s seafood restaurants?
While you can usually walk in, reservations are recommended on weekends or for larger groups, especially at popular spots like The White Whale and Gusto Divino Trattoria.
