For seafood lovers in Tallahassee, finding fresh, flavorful options can be a rewarding adventure. Over the years, I’ve sampled countless menus across the city, and each visit feels like uncovering a hidden treasure. The best spots serve seafood that’s been thoughtfully prepared—highlighting the natural sweetness of fish, the briny richness of oysters, and the tender succulence of shellfish. Tallahassee might be known for its southern charm and vibrant college town energy, but its seafood scene is equally impressive and worth exploring.
Whether you’re a longtime resident or just passing through, this guide aims to steer you toward the most reputable seafood establishments in Tallahassee, FL. These venues not only prioritize quality but also offer a variety of flavors and atmospheres to suit any mood. Rest assured, each choice has earned a reputation for excellence—delivering dishes that satisfy every craving without unnecessary fuss or exaggeration. Dive in, and discover the city’s true coastal flavors.
Where to find the best seafood in Tallahassee, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Tallahassee, FL:
- Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille
- Shell Oyster Bar
- Wahoo Seafood Grill
- Bird’s Aphrodisiac Oyster Shack
- Georgio’s Fine Food & Spirits
- Crystal River Seafood
- Bonefish Grill
- Wharf Casual Seafood
- Wharf Casual Seafood
- Chuck’s Fish
1. Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille
Located just off the Florida State University campus, Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille transports diners to the vibrant flavors of New Orleans with a touch of Southern hospitality. I once visited during a lively lunch hour, and the inviting atmosphere paired with the aroma of spicy Cajun dishes made it hard to leave. The restaurant’s location makes it ideal for a midday break or a fun evening out before a game.
What sets Harry’s apart is its commitment to authentic seafood and bold Creole-inspired flavors. The Seafood Boil is a must-try, bursting with fresh shellfish and flavorful spices—perfect for sharing or indulging solo. For a heartier option, the Gulf Shrimp & Grits exemplifies their style—rich, satisfying, and true to the Gulf Coast tradition. Harry’s ensures every dish showcases quality ingredients and a genuine taste of New Orleans.
2. Shell Oyster Bar
Shell Oyster Bar might look modest from the outside, but don’t let appearances fool you—it’s a Tallahassee staple with decades of trust behind its name. Tucked near FAMU Way, this no-frills spot delivers on its promise of simple, honest seafood. I stopped in on a hot afternoon, and the chilled oysters and friendly service turned a quick meal into something memorable.
Known for its unfussy setup and fresh flavors, Shell Oyster Bar is where locals go when they want seafood without pretension. The Fried Fish Sandwich is a favorite—crispy, flaky, and served with just enough kick to keep things interesting. You also can’t go wrong with a dozen raw oysters, shucked to order and served ice cold.
If you’re craving a laid-back meal where the focus is solely on freshness and taste, Shell delivers exactly that. It’s ideal for lunch or a no-fuss dinner that puts quality front and center.
3. Wahoo Seafood Grill
Wahoo Seafood Grill is a family-friendly spot that brings the zest of Cajun and Southern flavors to Tallahassee. I visited on a lively weekend brunch, and the warm, inviting atmosphere paired with the aroma of seasoned seafood made it an instant favorite. It’s a place where the whole family can relax and indulge in flavorful fare.
The restaurant’s emphasis on bold spices and fresh ingredients makes it stand out. The Cajun Shrimp Pasta is a standout—creamy, spicy, and packed with plump shrimp that reflect Wahoo’s commitment to authentic Louisiana-style cooking. The Fried Catfish is another must-try, crispy and tender, served with classic sides.
If you want a taste of Southern seafood done right, Wahoo Seafood Grill offers a variety of options that are both hearty and satisfying, prepared with care and authenticity.
4. Bird’s Aphrodisiac Oyster Shack
Bird’s Aphrodisiac Oyster Shack is a quirky, laid-back gem tucked in downtown Tallahassee. I first wandered in on a Thursday night, drawn by the buzz of live music and the scent of grilled seafood. The vibe was casual, the crowd friendly, and the food surprisingly refined for a place with picnic tables and graffiti-covered walls.
What makes Bird’s stand out is its unapologetic focus on flavor. The Oysters Rockefeller are rich and savory, layered with spinach and parmesan, while the Grouper Sandwich offers a flaky, well-seasoned fillet that’s grilled to perfection. Both dishes reflect the kitchen’s knack for balancing bold ingredients with simple execution.
If you’re after seafood with personality, Bird’s delivers. It’s not polished, but it’s real—and that’s what keeps people coming back.
5. Georgio’s Fine Food & Spirits
Georgio’s Fine Food & Spirits brings Mediterranean warmth to Tallahassee’s Apalachee Parkway. The moment you step inside, the scent of olive oil, fresh herbs, and grilled seafood sets the tone for a meal that feels both familiar and elevated. It’s not just dinner—it’s a sit-down with George or Eleni, if you’re lucky.
The menu blends local catch with old-world flavor. I recommend starting with the Grilled Gulf Shrimp, served with lemon and herbs, then moving on to the Fresh Snapper à la Grecque. Both showcase how Georgio’s takes Florida seafood and gives it a Hellenic twist.
Unlike chain spots, everything here is made from scratch. That extra care shows up in the details—perfect seasoning, attentive plating, and food that feels thoughtfully crafted.
Georgio’s is proof that seafood can be elevated without being fussy. You’re not just served—you’re welcomed.
6. Crystal River Seafood
Crystal River Seafood is a family-owned favorite in Tallahassee, known for serving fresh, reasonably priced seafood in a lively, welcoming setting. I visited on a busy weekend evening, and the cheerful atmosphere paired with the friendly staff made for a pleasant experience. The restaurant’s long-standing history of over 30 years speaks to its consistent quality.
The menu offers a wide variety of options, but I recommend the Gulf Shrimp and the Frog Legs—both are cooked to perfection and showcase their commitment to fresh, flavorful ingredients. For a heartier choice, their Certified Angus Ribeye complements the seafood offerings perfectly.
What truly sets Crystal River Seafood apart is its focus on fun, fresh dishes served with a smile—that’s the essence of good seafood dining in Tallahassee.
7. Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill in Tallahassee is a go-to for those seeking fresh, expertly prepared seafood in a relaxed setting. During a recent dinner, I appreciated the attentive service and the inviting atmosphere that encourages unwinding after a busy day. The focus on high-quality ingredients makes every dish stand out.
Their signature Wood-Grilled Fish offerings, like the salmon or Chilean seabass, showcase the restaurant’s commitment to flavor and quality. I also recommend the Bang Bang Shrimp as a perfect kickoff—crispy, spicy, and addictive. Pair these with a signature cocktail or a glass of locally curated wine for an elevated experience.
Bonefish Grill’s craftsmanship and-seasoned approach to seafood make it a top choice for a memorable, satisfying meal in Tallahassee.
8. Wharf Casual Seafood
Wharf Casual Seafood offers a relaxed dining experience right on Bannerman Road. During a recent visit, I found the atmosphere friendly and the service prompt, making it ideal for a quick lunch or casual dinner. Their focus on fresh, quality seafood keeps guests coming back.
The Fish Tacos are a standout—light, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned—ideal for a casual meal. For something heartier, the Seafood Platter with shrimp, fish, and oysters reflects their commitment to variety and freshness. The simplicity of their dishes highlights the quality of ingredients used.
For a laid-back seafood joint with honest flavors and good service, Wharf Casual Seafood delivers exactly what you need for an authentic Tallahassee experience.
9. Wharf Casual Seafood
Wharf Casual Seafood in Fallschase Village Center is a local favorite for unfussy, flavorful seafood. The vibe is relaxed, the service is quick, and the menu leans into Gulf Coast classics with a fresh twist. I stopped in for lunch and was greeted with warm smiles and the scent of sizzling shrimp.
What sets this spot apart is its consistency. The Wharf Shrimp Tacos are crisp, spicy, and layered with texture—exactly what you want when craving seafood without the fuss. The Destin Platter, loaded with grouper, shrimp, and crab cake, showcases their knack for balancing bold flavors with clean execution.
Whether you’re grabbing takeout or settling in for dinner, Wharf Casual Seafood delivers fresh, satisfying seafood that feels distinctly Tallahassee.
10. Chuck’s Fish
Chuck’s Fish on College Avenue blends upscale charm with Gulf Coast soul. The moment I walked in, the warm lighting and polished wood interiors set the tone—refined but not pretentious. Service was attentive without hovering, and the menu read like a love letter to fresh seafood.
What makes Chuck’s Fish stand out is its direct connection to Harbor Docks, their own seafood market in Destin. That means the Pan-Crusted Red Grouper and Stuffed Gulf Shrimp arrive impeccably fresh, with flavors that speak for themselves. The grouper was flaky and rich, paired with broccolini and risotto that didn’t try too hard.
If you’re into sushi, the Backdown Roll is a local favorite—clean, balanced, and beautifully plated. Chuck’s Fish delivers seafood with precision and personality.
More Things to Try in Tallahassee, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What’s the best seafood restaurant near Florida State University in Tallahassee?
A: Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille is a popular choice, offering authentic New Orleans flavors and a lively atmosphere. It’s perfect for lunch, dinner, or pre-game meals before football games.
Q: Are there casual seafood spots in Tallahassee suitable for takeout?
A: Yes. Places like Wharf Casual Seafood and Crystal River Seafood provide quick, fresh options for takeout without sacrificing quality.
Q: Do restaurants in Tallahassee offer gluten-free or vegetarian seafood options?
A: Many do, including Bonefish Grill and Wahoo Seafood Grill, which feature gluten-free dishes and vegetarian-friendly salads and sides.
Q: Can I find fine dining seafood in Tallahassee?
A: Absolutely. Georgio’s Fine Food & Spirits offers upscale seafood alongside Mediterranean dishes, perfect for special occasions.