The search for truly fresh seafood in a small town can feel like pursuing hidden treasure. Tappan, NY may seem quiet, but over the years I’ve uncovered an assortment of spectacular seafood spots that keep locals and visitors happily returning. Sometimes it’s the scent of garlic and butter over plump shellfish, sometimes a perfectly grilled fish that flakes at the touch. In Tappan and the surrounding area, each spot offers a different take—some old-school, some buzzworthy newcomers—always steering clear of anything that doesn’t meet the highest standards.
If you crave impeccable seafood cooked right, you’re in the right place. Whether I’m thinking of the unforgettable lobster at a local marina or a bowl of steamers shared with friends on a Friday evening, I’ve tried them all, so you won’t waste time on misses. Let’s take the guesswork out of your next meal. This roundup highlights the standouts, from cozy family-run favorites to bustling bistros, so you can settle in, order with confidence, and relish every bite. Dive in.
Where to find the best seafood in Tappan, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Tappan, NY:
- Il Portico
- Giulio’s
- Giulios Restaurant
- The Fish Dock
- Taste of Spain
- Stern & Bow
- Bread and Brine
- Cornetta’s Restaurant & Marina
- Anchor Seafood
- Rockland Seafood
1. Il Portico
Il Portico brings an unmistakable charm to Main Street with a blend of historic ambiance and Italian flair. Tucked inside a landmark building dating back to the 1850s, its rustic stone walls and candlelit tables make any meal feel like an occasion. Here, the focus on quality stands out—from attentive table service to carefully chosen ingredients.
The seafood at Il Portico is consistently impressive. The grilled branzino arrives perfectly moist, kissed with olive oil and a squeeze of fresh lemon. The frutti di mare—a vibrant seafood medley nestled in linguine—is packed with sweet shrimp, plump clams, and tender calamari in a lively tomato sauce.
Some meals linger in memory, and Il Portico’s seafood delivers every time. For a taste of Tappan that feels both comforting and refined, this is the spot to linger with good company over a delicious plate.
2. Giulio’s
Giulio’s sits in a stunning Victorian house where every corner invites you to linger a bit longer. The elegant woodwork, glowing fireplaces, and sweeping staircase create a scene that feels straight from a classic film. This isn’t just about ambiance—there’s real heart and skill in the kitchen here.
Seafood is where Giulio’s shines brightest. The linguine with shrimp and calamari brims with fresh flavors, the pasta catching every bit of delicate sauce. The filet of sole, pan-seared and finished with a dash of lemon and herbs, showcases their knack for graceful, understated cooking.
Each visit feels special, whether it’s an anniversary or just a craving for something memorable. Giulio’s delivers every time with consistent quality and a warm welcome.
3. Giulios Restaurant
Giulios Restaurant offers that rare blend of hometown warmth and elevated plates. The space has an inviting, timeless feel, perfect for gatherings both big and small. Here, generations of families cross paths, sharing dishes rooted in Italian and American tradition.
This spot’s seafood risotto is my go-to—creamy rice loaded with tender shrimp, scallops, and clams, all folded into a light, savory broth that carries just a hint of white wine. Another winner is the grilled salmon, beautifully seared, served with roasted vegetables and a drizzle of lemony olive oil.
Friendly service and a menu packed with classics make Giulios Restaurant a staple in Tappan. The attention to detail and genuine hospitality are as memorable as the food itself.
4. The Fish Dock
The Fish Dock makes seafood a true highlight just over the border from Tappan. Specializing in fish straight from Iceland, this market brings quality that feels rare—even in seasoned seafood towns. The pristine catch is flown in, often arriving less than two days after it leaves the water.
Fresh fillets here come alive with the clean taste of the ocean. The arctic char, mild and buttery, is a top pick, best enjoyed with a simple pan-sear to let its flavor shine. The cod loins are another staple worth the trip; they hold up well in hearty stews or as the star on your plate.
If you want sustainability, flavor, and variety, The Fish Dock raises the bar for local seafood lovers. Each visit feels like a direct connection to the North Atlantic.
5. Taste of Spain
(201) 767-8904Call
Taste of Spain is tucked away in Northvale, just a short drive from Tappan, and offers a genuine taste of coastal Spain. The moment you step in, the aroma of saffron and fresh seafood turns an ordinary evening into something special. The simple, unfussy atmosphere lets the food do the talking.
This spot’s seafood paella is boldly satisfying, brimming with mussels, shrimp, and tender squid nestled in fragrant rice. For something a little different, try the grilled octopus—it arrives silky and smoky, dressed with olive oil and paprika.
Every dish reflects traditional Spanish flavors, executed with care. When you’re in the mood for something with Mediterranean flair, Taste of Spain delivers authenticity and warmth with every bite.
6. Stern & Bow
Stern & Bow sits just minutes from Tappan and effortlessly blends an upbeat vibe with a touch of old-school charm. The dining room buzzes, yet polished touches make the experience feel special. Dark wood, live music, and a bustling open kitchen create a dynamic backdrop.
Seafood here is handled with skill and confidence. The whole roasted branzino is a star—tender, crisp-skinned, and bright with lemon and herbs. Another standout is their crab-stuffed sole, which balances richness and freshness without overpowering the fish itself.
Each plate is thoughtfully composed and served with genuine enthusiasm. For seafood packed with both flavor and style, Stern & Bow is a reliable bet for both date night and group outings.
7. Bread and Brine
Bread and Brine in Hastings On Hudson brings a fresh perspective to the local seafood scene. The casual vibe is welcoming, and the aromas drifting from the open kitchen always spark anticipation. There’s a sense of playfulness in their menu, but with a clear dedication to top-quality ingredients.
The oyster selection is always impressive—briny, cold, and impeccably shucked. For something heartier, try the New England clam chowder; it strikes the right balance between creamy and bright, with a generous helping of tender clams in every spoonful.
Whether you’re popping in for a quick snack or settling in for a full meal, Bread and Brine delivers. Their approach keeps classics vibrant and lets seafood truly shine.
8. Cornetta’s Restaurant & Marina
(845) 359-9852Call
Cornetta’s Restaurant & Marina is a fixture on the Piermont waterfront, serving up seafood with river views and a sense of nostalgia. The setting alone makes a meal here feel like an escape, especially on a sunny afternoon. Watching boats drift past while you dig into a fresh catch is hard to top.
The stuffed sole stands out, filled with delicate crabmeat and baked just right. The grilled salmon is just as memorable, arriving perfectly cooked, moist, and topped with a simple lemon-herb sauce.
Cornetta’s manages to keep things classic without feeling dated. It’s a great pick for anyone looking to unwind by the water and enjoy seafood done with traditional care.
9. Anchor Seafood
Anchor Seafood in Montvale is a hidden gem for those serious about quality. This market and eatery has built a loyal following for its impressively fresh selection and approachable atmosphere. The kind of place where staff are happy to chat about the catch of the day and share preparation tips.
The grilled swordfish steak is a clear standout—firm, juicy, and flawlessly seasoned. Another highlight is the shrimp sauté, generous in portion and skillfully cooked to lock in sweetness and snap.
No fuss, just thoughtfully prepared seafood that makes you want to linger a little longer. Anchor Seafood is ideal for anyone who values freshness and a genuine, local touch.
10. Rockland Seafood
(845) 624-3660Call
Rockland Seafood in Nanuet has long been my answer for reliable, super-fresh seafood. Tucked along Route 304, it’s a neighborhood favorite where quality is never in question and the selection makes cooking at home a pleasure.
The market’s fresh scallops are as sweet and plump as you’ll find anywhere. For an easy weeknight dinner, grab the house-made seafood salad—packed with tender shrimp and a bright, tangy dressing, it’s an easy win.
Staff here always know their stuff and are quick with spot-on recommendations. Rockland Seafood stays true to its roots, offering a no-nonsense approach to top-tier seafood that lets the ingredients shine.
More Things to Try in Tappan, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants near Tappan, NY?
Top picks include Il Portico, Giulio’s, The Fish Dock, and Cornetta’s Restaurant & Marina. Each spot offers fresh, well-prepared seafood and a memorable atmosphere.
Which places in Tappan offer the freshest seafood?
The Fish Dock stands out for its rapid delivery of Icelandic catch. Anchor Seafood and Rockland Seafood are also favorites for their consistently fresh selections.
Are there any seafood options with waterfront views?
Cornetta’s Restaurant & Marina offers classic seafood dishes with sweeping river views, perfect for a relaxed meal by the water.
Do any Tappan seafood restaurants offer gluten-free or vegetarian options?
Il Portico and Bread and Brine cater to a range of diets, including gluten-free and vegetarian, alongside their seafood specialties.
Can I find sustainable and responsibly sourced seafood in Tappan?
Yes. The Fish Dock prioritizes sustainability by sourcing directly from Iceland’s well-managed fisheries, while Anchor Seafood is known for its commitment to responsible sourcing.
