Finding truly good seafood in Whitehall, OH can feel like searching for pearls in an oyster bed. You want the real thing: shrimp with snap, flaky fish with flavor, and maybe even crab legs worth rolling up your sleeves for. If you’ve been circling the same tired menus and ending up disappointed, you’re about to strike gold.
I’ve spent more dinners than I care to count exploring hidden gems, neighborhood favorites, and spots with ocean-fresh reputations. This guide gathers the very best seafood restaurants Whitehall has to offer, based squarely on lived experience and a keen sense of what makes seafood stand out. Whether you’re craving grilled, fried, or something spicy with that unmistakable seafood zest, you’ll find a spot here that gets it right—without wading through mediocrity. Get ready to discover a lineup that makes even inland Ohio feel a little closer to the coast.
1. Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen
Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen on E Main St knows what crispy means. Walk in, and you’ll be greeted by the aromas of batter-fried perfection—light, flaky, and never greasy. This spot delivers quick, no-nonsense seafood, perfectly cooked and packed with flavor.
If you haven’t been before, start with their classic battered fish. The crunch is spot on, and the fish inside is tender every single time. The Butterfly Shrimp, light but flavorful, is a must if you’re chasing that classic coastal craving.
Captain D’s isn’t just about speed; it’s about consistent, comforting seafood favorites. It’s a great place to round up the family or swing by for a solo fried fish fix. For a true Captain D’s experience, order the seafood platter and taste why this place remains a local favorite.
2. Pier Boiling Seafood
Pier Boiling Seafood, tucked into the Town & Country Shopping Center, brings the joy of fresh seafood boils to Whitehall with true flair. This spot knows how to keep things lively and flavorful. When I visited with friends, we dove into bags of seasoned crab and shrimp, hands messy but spirits high.
What makes Pier Boiling Seafood special is the build-your-own seafood boil—pick your seafood, spice level, and sauce, then watch it all come together in one savory steam. Their garlic butter sauce clings to every morsel and keeps you reaching back for more.
For a rich experience, order the snow crab legs or mix things up with shrimp and corn. Each visit feels laid-back and satisfying, with plenty of big, bold flavor.
3. Fisher Fish & Chicken
Fisher Fish & Chicken has a knack for cooking up seafood that feels both generous and satisfying. On my visit, the hush of fryers gave way to golden-brown fillets, piping hot and just waiting to be unwrapped. This place thrives on comfort food done right.
The whiting and tilapia fillets stand out for their flaky freshness and flavor-packed breading. Each bite delivers simple goodness—never overdone or oily. Their jumbo shrimp, lightly seasoned, is addictive and served with just the right amount of crunch.
If you’re craving a combo, their fish and shrimp platter balances great value with big flavors. Fisher Fish & Chicken is perfect for seafood lovers who like their meals quick, hearty, and reliably tasty.
4. Cajun Boiling Seafood
Cajun Boiling Seafood on Brice Rd brings Southern flavor right to the edge of Whitehall. The smell of Cajun spices hits you at the door, and you know you’re in for an experience—not just a meal. This isn’t your basic seafood spot; every visit feels like a celebration of bold, zesty flavors.
Pick your seafood, select your spice, and get ready to make a mess. The crawfish and shrimp boils here deliver heaps of juicy, tender seafood, drenched in garlicky, buttery sauce. Their seasoning stands out—there’s a warmth to every bite, but the flavor never overpowers the freshness.
The combo platter is a top move if you want to taste a bit of everything. Cajun Boiling Seafood is for anyone longing for a seafood meal with real kick, and a menu that lets you soak up every last drop with a side of corn or potatoes.
5. Red Lobster
Red Lobster on S Hamilton Rd is a classic, and there’s a reason it still draws seafood fans. The menu brings dependable favorites in a casual setting—great for group dinners, family meals, or when you want something a touch special but still easygoing.
My last visit was all about the fresh salmon. The texture was silky and the grill marks sealed in robust, ocean-kissed flavor. Their Cheddar Bay Biscuits live up to the hype, too—soft, warm, and impossible to eat just one.
If you haven’t tried their shrimp scampi yet, it’s a winner. Each plate balances buttery garlic and bright lemon, hitting all the right notes for a crowd-pleasing seafood fix. Red Lobster is a go-to when you want reliable seafood, generous portions, and a laid-back energy.
6. Marino’s Seafood
Marino’s Seafood on W 5th Ave is old-school in the best way. Walking in feels a bit like time travel—a reminder that great seafood doesn’t need to chase trends. This place gets by on quality fish, a loyal following, and plates that feel like home.
On my visit, the fish and chips were hand-breaded, flaky, and not a hint of greasiness in sight. There’s a no-frills energy here; everything stays focused on delivering pure, honest flavor.
If you’re after simplicity done right, try the whiting or perch. Each bite brings you back to the basics—just fresh seafood cooked to crisp perfection. Marino’s is a great bet for anyone who wants tradition, skill, and a taste that’s stood the test of time.
7. McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood Restaurant
McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood Restaurant at Easton really knows how to set a scene. High ceilings, white linen tables, and an energy that tells you you’re in for a real meal. This is the spot to celebrate or simply spoil yourself with seafood that’s a cut above.
Every time I’ve dined here, the menu has delivered something memorable—the grilled mahi mahi made the biggest impression. Each fillet was firm, juicy, and paired with fresh veggies that let the fish shine.
If you’re looking for something classic, the broiled salmon or seafood-stuffed sole are both winners. McCormick & Schmick’s stands out for attention to detail, elegant flavors, and seafood that actually tastes fresh from the coast.
8. Columbus Fish Market
Columbus Fish Market is where fresh seafood gets the spotlight it deserves. Step in, and you’ll notice the bustling raw bar and a retail fish case that hints at just how much pride goes into their daily catch. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between polished and approachable.
On my latest visit, the Shanghai-style sea bass was the showstopper—tender, juicy, and layered with nuanced flavors that let the fish take center stage. Everything on the menu feels intentional, from simple grilled fillets to subtly spiced seafood combos.
The crab cakes are another standout. Light on filler and heavy on sweet crab, they set a high bar for the city. Columbus Fish Market is the spot for diners who love having choices and crave seafood done right, every single time.
9. Mitchell’s Ocean Club
Mitchell’s Ocean Club at Easton is the kind of place you reserve for occasions that deserve more than just dinner. This is luxury with a pulse—white tablecloths, sparkling glassware, and dishes that look as good as they taste. The lighting sets the mood, and the energy is always upbeat.
My first visit included their signature Chilean sea bass, and it holds up as one of the most memorable plates I’ve had in Columbus. Perfectly cooked, buttery, and balanced with a bright glaze that stays with you.
If you’re searching for a standout starter, try their jumbo lump crab cocktail—clean, sweet crabmeat with just a touch of zest. Mitchell’s Ocean Club is a must for anyone who views seafood as a real dining adventure.
10. Fish & Chicken Inn
(614) 478-0675Call
Fish & Chicken Inn on E Hudson St does fried seafood like it’s a calling. Swing by and you’ll notice locals popping in for quick orders, drawn by the kitchen’s promise of consistently hot, fresh food. There’s no glitz—just the comfort of classic, no-fuss cooking.
When I stopped in, the fried fish dinner stood out, cooked to crispy, golden perfection with a moist, flavorful center. Their catfish and whiting are top picks, each fillet boasting a light breading that keeps the focus on the fish itself.
If you want a little variety, go for the combo platter. It’s ideal for sampling their best seafood selections, and the generous portions mean you won’t go home hungry. Fish & Chicken Inn is proof that you don’t need bells and whistles to deliver a great seafood meal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants near Whitehall, OH?
Some favorites include Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen for quick comfort seafood, Pier Boiling Seafood for customizable seafood boils, and Columbus Fish Market for a slightly upscale, fresh take on classic dishes. Each offers something unique for seafood lovers.
Where can I find fresh fish in Whitehall?
Many local spots, like Marino’s Seafood and Columbus Fish Market, pride themselves on bringing in fresh catches daily. Check their retail cases or ask staff for what’s best that day if you’re looking for truly fresh fish to eat or take home.
Can I get seafood for takeout or delivery?
Most seafood restaurants in the Whitehall area, such as Captain D’s and Red Lobster, offer takeout and even delivery through popular apps. It’s a great option for enjoying your favorites at home.
Are there seafood options for families?
Yes! Spots like Red Lobster and Captain D’s have kid-friendly menus and family-style platters, making it easy for everyone to find something they’ll enjoy.
What’s the best dish to try for a first-time visitor?
Start with a classic: battered fish at Captain D’s for a traditional bite, or a customizable seafood boil at Pier Boiling Seafood if you want some adventure. Crab cakes or grilled salmon at Columbus Fish Market are also crowd-pleasers with plenty of flavor.