Finding great seafood in Yorktown, NY can feel like hunting for pearls in the Hudson Valley. When you land on the right place, it’s not just about a meal—it’s the kind of discovery you want to share, but also want to keep as your own secret. After years of exploring local favorites and hidden gems (including a few under-the-radar market counters that surprised me with the freshest catch), I’ve gathered a list so you can skip the guesswork.
Yorktown’s seafood scene is a mix of old-school markets, casual tables, and some truly creative kitchens. Whether you crave straightforward fillets, love the clink of oyster shells at a lively grill, or just want a classic fish and chips done right, these spots have you covered. This guide pulls together only spots that pay attention to quality, flavor, and a welcoming atmosphere—everything you need for a perfect seafood outing or take-home feast. Get ready to discover your new favorite place.
1. Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc
(914) 666-6929Call
Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc has been a staple for fresh fish since 1894. The story starts with family tradition and the scent of the sea tucked away on Main Street. Every visit, I’m greeted by displays that show off the day’s best catch—always sparkling and never stale.
Their reputation comes not just from longevity, but from how they curate their menu and retail counter. Whether you want to dine in or grab something to cook at home, the staff guides you to the freshest picks of the day. It’s not unusual to see customers coming in for generations, a testament to their legacy.
I recommend the grilled Swordfish steak or their classic baked cod. Each dish brings clean flavors that give the seafood room to shine without excess fuss. If you like a more robust option, their shrimp and scallop platters never disappoint.
2. Mt Kisco Seafood
Mt Kisco Seafood proves that you don’t need to head to the coast for unforgettable seafood. Tucked conveniently on Lexington Ave, this spot balances old-school fishmonger know-how with a modern market feel. Clean counters and knowledgeable staff signal you’re in the right place for quality.
I’ve stopped by countless times and have never left disappointed. The staff are quick to suggest options, whether you want wild-caught filets or need inspiration for dinner. They source with care, so every product is dependable.
The signature lobster rolls and their classic New England clam chowder are unmatched in the area. For those who love grilling, the fresh salmon portions are some of the best around—firm, bright, and full of natural flavor.
3. Rick’s Seafood
(845) 621-2489Call
Rick’s Seafood brings a small-town vibe to serious seafood lovers right on Route 6. This family-owned spot is all about straightforward, quality offerings with a touch of local charm. Stepping in, I noticed the friendly buzz—regulars chatting with staff, seafood glistening behind glass.
Rick’s focus is on freshness, and it shows in every order. Whether you’re picking up raw fish or sitting down for a meal, the quality is consistent and impressive. There’s a genuine investment in delivering top-tier seafood without overcomplicating the process.
The fried flounder sandwich and the crab cakes are menu highlights. Both showcase their approach—minimal seasoning, letting the clean, sweet flavor of fresh seafood take the center stage. It’s a spot worth discovering if you care about simple, honest seafood.
4. Mt Kisco Smokehouse
Mt Kisco Smokehouse turns simple seafood into something memorable. The smell of perfectly smoked fish hits you as soon as you walk in, promising a treat before you’ve even seen the menu. The counter here is full of options you don’t find just anywhere in Westchester.
I’ve picked up their smoked salmon more times than I can count, and it never disappoints. Smooth, silky, and balanced with just the right hint of smoke, it elevates any bagel or brunch spread. The staff are happy to offer recommendations and samples for the curious.
Don’t skip the smoked whitefish salad or the peppered salmon. Both demonstrate the smokehouse’s careful technique and knack for delivering bold flavor while keeping the fish’s freshness front and center.
5. On the Spot for Spot
(914) 930-1242Call
On the Spot for Spot is the kind of tucked-away eatery you almost want to keep secret. It’s unpretentious, focusing on what matters most: seafood that tastes like it was caught that morning. I stumbled in on a rainy afternoon and found the cozy space perfect for a casual seafood fix.
This spot leans into comfort food done right, without shortcuts or distractions. The kitchen pays close attention to freshness and detail, so each meal feels thoughtfully prepared. Service is friendly, making quick work of any cravings.
The standout here is their classic fish fry or grilled shrimp plate. Both showcase ingredients let their flavor speak for themselves, with crisp textures and bright seasoning that stays true to the seafood-first philosophy.
6. Ravenna Osteria
(914) 736-0292Call
Ravenna Osteria blends the heart of Italian tradition with the freshest regional seafood. Tucked on North Division Street, this warm restaurant is always full of lively conversation and the inviting aroma of classic Mediterranean dishes. I’ve been swept away by the rustic charm and bright flavors every visit.
The kitchen has a knack for marrying robust sauces with the clean taste of local catches. Every plate feels like it’s been handled with care and seasoned with intent. Attentive staff and a cozy atmosphere wrap up the experience in the best way possible.
The seafood linguine or branzino al forno will impress anyone who loves seafood with an Italian twist. Both dishes are balanced, highlighting the quality of the seafood without losing that genuine osteria touch.
7. Purdy’s Farmer & The Fish
Purdy’s Farmer & The Fish brings together farm-fresh ingredients and top-tier seafood in a setting that feels equal parts rustic and sophisticated. Every visit is a reminder of how seamless the farm-to-table experience can be when done well. The cozy dining room and a view of the gardens set the mood for an unhurried meal.
The standout here is the commitment to using produce grown steps from the kitchen and seafood brought in daily. Everything tastes vibrant and thoughtful, from appetizers to mains. Staff are quick with suggestions, lending the meal a personal touch.
Favorites include the local oyster platters and the fisherman’s stew. Both showcase the kitchen’s knack for letting the freshness of each ingredient shine, with flavors that are clean, distinct, and deeply satisfying.
8. Tsagarakis Pete
(914) 271-2059Call
Tsagarakis Pete keeps things simple, focusing on fresh seafood with a distinctly local touch. This spot on South Riverside Ave feels both welcoming and unassuming, the kind of place you stumble on and remember.
The atmosphere is easygoing, with service that rings true to the neighborhood vibe. Each time I’ve visited, I’ve noticed the care they take in preparing even the basics. You taste the freshness and attention with every bite.
The grilled sole and broiled scallops are top picks. Each dish arrives perfectly cooked—not masked by heavy sauces, but allowed to stand on their own. Tsagarakis Pete proves that less is more when great seafood is involved.
9. Brothers Fish & Chips
Brothers Fish & Chips makes good on the promise in its name—classic seafood done with serious skill. From the outside, it looks unpretentious, but step in and you’ll quickly sense the energy and pride behind the counter. I was struck by the freshness of their ingredients and the way every dish arrived piping hot.
This spot stands out for perfecting the balance between crispy batter and tender seafood. It’s just as much a go-to for a quick lunch as it is for a laid-back dinner. The atmosphere is bright and friendly, adding to the comfort-food appeal.
The fish and chips are the gold standard here, but the fried shrimp plate is a close second. Both highlight Brothers’ ability to keep flavors pure, letting the quality and freshness do all the talking.
10. Briarcliff Seafood Meats
(914) 923-3240Call
Briarcliff Seafood Meats is where you go when you want unfussy, high-quality seafood in a friendly, neighborhood setting. Tucked on Pleasantville Road, the shop doubles as a seafood market and casual restaurant, giving you the best of both worlds. Every visit feels like stopping by a trusted family friend’s kitchen.
The freshness here is consistent, and the staff bring real knowledge to their recommendations. The counter is always stocked, and their preparations are straightforward but masterful. There’s never a doubt the focus is squarely on the seafood.
The broiled salmon or shrimp platters are standouts. Both deliver clean, fresh flavors that are a perfect match for anyone craving classic seafood. Briarcliff keeps it simple, and that’s exactly why it works.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants near Yorktown, NY?
Some standout options include Conte’s Quality Seafood, Mt Kisco Seafood, and Brothers Fish & Chips. Each brings something unique, from classic fried fish to expertly grilled fillets.
Where can I find the freshest seafood in Yorktown?
Local markets like Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc and Briarcliff Seafood Meats are go-to spots for fresh catch daily. These places have built a reputation for dependably high quality.
Are there seafood options for takeout or catering?
Yes—many places, such as Mt Kisco Smokehouse and Rick’s Seafood, offer both takeout and catering menus. It’s a popular way to enjoy seafood at home or for special gatherings.
Which seafood dishes should I try in the area?
The lobster rolls at Mt Kisco Seafood, fish and chips from Brothers Fish & Chips, and grilled salmon at Briarcliff Seafood Meats are favorites for good reason: fresh ingredients and honest preparation.
Is it easy to find halal or vegetarian seafood dishes?
Some restaurants will accommodate special requests, so it’s worth calling ahead. Simpler preparations like grilled or steamed fish are good options, and most menus offer at least one vegetarian side or seafood salad.
