For seafood lovers in Youngstown, OH, the search for the perfect meal can feel like a treasure hunt. Navigating through bustling eateries and hidden gems, the quest often leads to unexpected delights that satisfy cravings for the ocean’s bounty. With a variety of options, from casual spots to more upscale venues, this city has something to offer every palate. Each restaurant brings its own flavor and charm, making the seafood scene here a delightful experience worth exploring.
Throughout my culinary adventures, I’ve discovered that a great seafood dish can transport you. There’s a unique joy in savoring a perfectly steamed lobster or biting into crispy fish tacos while surrounded by good company. This article will guide you through the best seafood spots in Youngstown, revealing local favorites and hidden treasures. Whether you’re a fan of classic dishes or are eager to try something new, get ready to discover places that could become your next go-to dining destinations.
1. Steamers Stonewall Tavern
Steamers Stonewall Tavern, located at 10078 Market St, North Lima, Youngstown, OH, is a beloved local gem offering vegetarian-friendly and gluten-free options. Known for its warm ambiance and exceptional service, this tavern is perfect for lunch, dinner, or a late-night meal.
My visit to Steamers Stonewall Tavern was unforgettable. The cozy, inviting atmosphere coupled with friendly staff made for a delightful dining experience. The highlight was the seafood, which truly stands out.
For seafood lovers, the Crab Cakes and Seafood Alfredo are must-tries. The crab cakes are perfectly seasoned and crispy, while the rich, creamy Seafood Alfredo showcases the tavern’s commitment to quality and flavor.
Whether dining in or opting for takeout, Steamers Stonewall Tavern promises a memorable culinary adventure.
2. Red Lobster
Red Lobster, located at 1410 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown, OH, is a well-known establishment that promises a diverse seafood experience. Known for its warm hospitality and extensive menu, it’s an excellent choice for both lunch and dinner.
During my visit, the signature Endless Shrimp promotion caught my attention, and I was not disappointed. The atmosphere is lively, making it perfect for families or casual meals with friends.
What sets Red Lobster apart is its commitment to quality, and the Lobster Linguini reflects this beautifully; it’s creamy, flavorful, and generously portioned. Don’t miss out on the famous Cheddar Bay Biscuits—a delightful, buttery addition to any meal.
Red Lobster is a reliable destination for seafood lovers eager to enjoy fresh, delicious dishes.
3. Long John Silver’s
+1 330-759-1328
Long John Silver’s, located at 3560 Belmont Avenue, Youngstown, OH, is a fast-casual seafood joint that’s hard to beat for quick bites. Known for its emphasis on real seafood sourced from reliable waters, this spot features wild-caught Alaska pollock, salmon, and North Pacific cod.
My experience at Long John Silver’s was refreshing; the casual vibe made it a great choice for a laid-back lunch. The crispy batter on the fish delivers that nostalgic fast-food experience, but with a touch of quality.
For a satisfying meal, the classic Fish and Chips is a must-try—it offers perfectly fried fish alongside that crispy, golden coating. Don’t forget to grab some Hush Puppies as a delightful sidekick.
Long John Silver’s combines fast service with fresh flavors, making it a standout choice for fried seafood cravings.
4. Crabby Bob’s Crab Co.
Crabby Bob’s Crab Co., nestled at 3917 Belmont Ave, Youngstown, OH, is a vibrant spot that captures the essence of coastal dining. With a menu that spans seafood, American fare, and hearty steaks, it offers something for everyone.
On my visit, the lively atmosphere buzzed with excitement, and the staff made us feel right at home. What really stands out is their dedication to quality seafood, served in generous portions.
Do not miss the Crab Louie Salad; it’s fresh and loaded with succulent crab meat and zesty dressing that enhances the flavors. The Seafood Alfredo is another standout, with creamy sauce enveloping perfectly cooked seafood.
Crabby Bob’s Crab Co. provides a delightful blend of flavors, making it a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts.
5. Storming Crab
Storming Crab, located at 6651 South Ave, Youngstown, OH, brings a unique twist to the seafood dining experience. With a casual vibe and a focus on fresh ingredients, this restaurant makes grabbing a bite feel both fun and flavorful.
During my visit, the engaging atmosphere made it easy to unwind while the aroma of seafood filled the air. Their unique approach encourages diners to get hands-on, turning the meal into an experience.
The Seafood Boil is a must-order; it features a blend of shrimp, crab, and sausage soaked in flavorful seasonings that leave you craving more. Pair it with delicious Cajun Fries for the perfect side.
Storming Crab offers an enjoyable escape for seafood lovers wanting something a little different.
6. Long John Silver’s | Taco Bell
+1 330-505-0803
Long John Silver’s | Taco Bell in Youngstown, OH offers a unique blend of fast-food favorites with a focus on real seafood sourced from the oceans. Located at 850 N. Canfield Niles Rd., this spot is perfect for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.
My visit to Long John Silver’s | Taco Bell was a delightful experience. The moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly prepared seafood was inviting. The friendly staff made me feel welcome and were quick to suggest their best dishes.
Why does Long John Silver’s | Taco Bell stand out? It’s their commitment to quality. They use wild-caught Alaska pollock, salmon, and north Pacific cod, ensuring every bite is fresh and flavorful.
When you visit, don’t miss out on the wild-caught Alaska salmon or the north Pacific cod. These dishes perfectly showcase the restaurant’s dedication to sourcing the best seafood, making it a standout choice in Youngstown, OH.
7. Blue Wolf Tavern
Nestled in the heart of Youngstown, OH, Blue Wolf Tavern blends warm hospitality with a rustic, upscale charm. From the moment I walked in, the inviting ambiance and friendly service made it feel like a local favorite with a refined touch.
What truly sets Blue Wolf Tavern apart is its commitment to fresh, quality ingredients and an innovative menu. It’s not just a place to eat—it’s an experience that captures the essence of both comfort and creativity. The tavern-style setting adds to its cozy yet elegant vibe.
If you’re a seafood lover, don’t miss the Pan-Seared Atlantic Salmon—perfectly cooked and served with seasonal vegetables, showcasing the chef’s mastery. The Shrimp Scampi is another standout, rich in flavor and beautifully plated.
Blue Wolf Tavern is a must-visit for anyone craving elevated seafood in a welcoming setting.
8. Hook Fish and Chicken
Hook Fish and Chicken, located at 2545 Belmont Ave, Youngstown, OH, is a casual eatery that focuses on delivering delicious seafood and chicken. The moment I stepped inside, the mouthwatering aroma hinted at the delights that awaited.
What makes Hook Fish and Chicken special is its commitment to simplicity and flavor. The friendly atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. The staff is always ready with recommendations, enhancing the experience.
For seafood enthusiasts, the Fried Catfish is a must-try; it’s crispy on the outside and tender inside. Pair it with their Coleslaw for a refreshing contrast. You won’t be disappointed.
Hook Fish and Chicken promises satisfying dishes that keep you coming back for more.
9. Galaxy Seafood
+1 330-707-4584
Located at 1722 Belmont Ave, Galaxy Seafood offers a distinctive seafood experience in Youngstown, OH. From the moment I walked in, the vibrant atmosphere and friendly service made it clear that this place is a haven for seafood lovers.
What sets Galaxy Seafood apart is its commitment to quality and freshness. The menu features a variety of dishes, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The casual, welcoming vibe makes it an ideal spot for a relaxed meal with friends or family.
The Fried Shrimp is a standout; it’s perfectly golden and bursting with flavor. Pair it with their Homemade Tartar Sauce for an added kick. Don’t miss the Seafood Platter for a taste of everything.
Galaxy Seafood is a delightful destination for anyone craving fresh seafood in a laid-back environment.
10. A Taste Of Seafood And More
+1 330-550-9594
Nestled in Youngstown, OH, A Taste Of Seafood And More offers a cozy, hometown experience with bold Southern-inspired flavors. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh seafood and spices welcomes you like family. It’s a hidden gem for those craving authentic, flavorful seafood in a laid-back setting.
What sets this spot apart is its generous portions, friendly service, and a menu that boasts halal-friendly seafood dishes with a homemade touch. The chef clearly takes pride in every plate, and it shows.
I highly recommend the catfish dinner—crispy on the outside, tender inside, and perfectly seasoned. Pair it with the garlic butter shrimp and a side of mac and cheese for the full experience.
A Taste Of Seafood And More is a must-visit for seafood lovers in Youngstown.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best seafood restaurants in Youngstown, OH?
Some top choices include Steamers Stonewall Tavern, Red Lobster, Crabby Bob’s Crab Co., and Storming Crab. Each offers unique menus and atmospheres, catering to different tastes.
2. Do any seafood restaurants in Youngstown offer takeout?
Yes, many seafood restaurants in Youngstown, including Long John Silver’s and Blue Wolf Tavern, provide takeout options, allowing you to enjoy their dishes at home.
3. What should I order at a seafood restaurant in Youngstown?
Must-try dishes include fried catfish, crab cakes, and seafood pasta. Each restaurant has its specialties, so don’t hesitate to ask the staff for recommendations.
4. Are there vegetarian or gluten-free options at seafood restaurants?
Many seafood spots in Youngstown offer vegetarian-friendly and gluten-free options. Restaurants like Steamers Stonewall Tavern cater to various dietary needs.
5. What is the price range for seafood meals in Youngstown?
The price varies by restaurant, but you can typically expect to pay between $10 and $30 per person, depending on the dishes you choose and whether it’s casual or fine dining.